Julie K Eliza Flat Tote VS. Yves Saint Laurent Tribute Tote

While browsing around Couture Candy, I came across a bag that looked quite familiar. It was called the Eliza Flat Tote in Black Patent by Julie K, but I knew that Julie K wasn’t the high fashion designer I was thinking of that made this bag. It suddenly clicked in my head that this handbag looked like, none other than, the Yves Saint Laurent Tribute Flat Tote. Suddenly the handbag wasn’t as appealing to me anymore.

(above: Tribute on sale at bluefly)
The Yves Saint Laurent Tribute Tote can cost you anywhere from about $900-$1,400, and to see another designer basically make a look-a-like version of the handbag, for a fraction of the price, is a little appalling. I understand handbag lovers worldwide may think this handbag is amazing, because they can get a handbag that resembles a Yves Saint Laurent Tribute Tote for a more affordable price. When you think about it though, is this case any different than that of Forever 21?
Forever 21 is known for stealing ideas from high fashion designers, and selling a horribly fake version at the store. How is that case any different than what Julie K did? You decide for yourself.
Some details of the Julie K Flat Tote include: fuchsia lining; interior pockets; brass hardware; magnetic closure; and 100% genuine black patent leather. The measurements of the handbag are 16” W x 18” L making the handbag perfect for when you have quite a few stylish essentials to carry.
The Eliza Flat Tote in Black Patent can be purchased at Couture Candy for $473, which is a little expensive for a handbag that resembles a high fashion handbag. I will say though, if you always loved the Yves Saint Laurent Tribute Tote this can be your chance to get a handbag that looks like it was inspired by it to the fullest.
See the Julie K Eliza Flat Tote in Black Patent at: Couture Candy
The Chat: Eliza Flat VS. Yves Saint Laurent
This entry was posted on Thursday, April 9th, 2009 at 10:20 am and is filed under Bag Trend Alert, Designer Totes, Handbags, Other Designer Handbags & Purses, Replica & Inspired Handbags, Would u Wear This?, Yves Saint Laurent (YSL) Handbags & Purses. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Follow us












I love the tribute.. thanks for the deal alert. Now I’m hoping they get a black one in stock.
I have never heard of that designer, and imo I think it is way overpriced.
I like both of the bags.
I actually have both of these bags. Really they are very different when compared to eachother.
And YSL did NOT invent the flat sac. That style has been around for years.
I like both bags, and I think they both look similar but not enough to scream replica.
I love this bag!
Wow, I’m surprised that one is so expensive.
I don’t think I would ever buy that Julie bag, unless it were on sale for like $100.
I love the tribute, that other one is trash.
Next 4 comments in The Bag Forum. Visit to continue reading
I love the YSL flat tote.. I would never trade it for a Julie K in for a million years.
The Julie K handbag definitely looks like a replica!
that bag looks WAY too similar to the YSL...come on, can you think of your own ideas? I LOVE my YSL tribute tote and it is way awesomer than that other bag lol.
I hate inspired bags...so the YSL gets my vote.